Friday, November 21, 2014

A Leader Like No Other


Never underestimate the power of a man who fights for what he believes in. The strength of man when the masses rise are almost impossible to overcome. In Saint Domingue, 1791, one man, Toussaint Louverture. finally said enough was enough, and he took matters into his own hands. The biggest slave revolt in history was about to happen. Toussaint fought for what he believed in. He was a true fighter for freedom and abolishment of slavery, and no matter what side supported the slaves, that would be the side he joined. In 1793, Toussaint was in control of an army of rebels and slaves that consisted of over four thousand men. They fought the French to the death and eventually abolished slavery in 1794. Now that the French supported the slaves, Toussaint joined them and became the ruler of the French army, making him the most powerful person in the island. St. Domingue was the western half of Hispaniola, and it was ruled by the French. They produced many crops such as sugar and coffee, and without the island France would have had trouble surviving. Toussaint ruled this part of the island until 1802, until Napoleon came and attacked the French army, trying to reinstate slavery. Eventually Napoleon retreated, but Toussaint was captured and died in jail. The question, "how should we remember Toussaint Louverture?" Is a very good question because there are many different things that he can be indent infield as. Toussaint Louverture should be remembered as the liberator so slaves, his ability to be a great military leader, and his job as commander of Saint Domingue. Although his military leadership and ruler of saint Domingue is important, his ability to liberate slaves is the most important because he was the successful leader of the biggest slave revolt in history.

The slave revolt that took place in Saint Domingue was the most important, and most successful slave revolt in history, and it was able to happen because of Toussaint Louverture. In 1791, the slave revolt began, and Toussaint Louverture joins the rebellion as a doctor (A). In 1792, he began to lead the army and taught his troops how to fight in different styles, like European battle and guerrilla style (A). Before this, in 1789, the French Revolution began and free black men of color in saint Domingue proclaimed themselves French citizens (A). The declaration of rights of men triggered the slave revolt once white men refused to end slavery. Once the revolution was over, and Toussaint and the slaves were free, the French directory was the government that ruled France. They ruled from 1795 to 1799, and Toussaint believed that they were going to reinstate slavery (B). Toussaint wrote a letter to the directory saying that if they were to attempt to reinstate slavery, then it would be impossible. He says that once men get a taste of what liberty is like they will never go back to being enslaved. The threat in the letter says that if slavery comes back there will be another war (B). In 1801, Toussaint led and assembled Saint Domingue's Constitution, which promised rules and policies that would keep former slaves free (C). On example, from article 3 of the constitution, says "there cannot exist slaves in this territory! servitude is therein forever abolished. All men are born and die free and French." This shows with great emphasis on how much Toussaint cared about keeping slaves free. He cared about social and economic welfare, and preserved the liberation of slaves, making him a very honorable man.

One of the main reasons Toussaint was about to be so successful in his revolution was because of how great of a military commander he was. HIs ability both on and off the battlefield was superior to others, and without him in control, the revolution would have failed. One example is that Toussaint trained him men in multiple tactics of war, thus giving them an advantage when on the battlefield (A). Also, when Toussaint began to force labor back onto the plantations, and a revolt occurred on the night of October 29, 1801, he stuck to his roots and did not let the mutineer get his way (E). He forced Moyse, who was Toussaint's adopted nephew, to be arrested and executed (E). This shows that Toussaint would not let anyone get out of control while he was in command, and he was able to react quickly to soldiers and plantation workers who were out of place. Another example was when Napoleon came and attacked Saint Domingue. When Toussaint saw the ships, he burned down the city and took him and his troops to the mountains (F). He fled there because his troops were familiar with the territory, whereas Napoleons men were not. This would give them the ability to run a guerilla war type of battle and force the European army away (F). He burned down the city so Napoleon's troops would have no base to set up at, and all the resources that could have been used were gone (F). Smart moves like this showed how great of a military commander Toussaint Louverture was, and his success on the battlefield brought Saint Domingue to peace.

Not only was Toussaint a military leader, but he was the ruler of Saint Domingue, and in 1801, he was able to create Saint Domingue's Constitution of 1801. This allowed more than just slavery to never occur again. It helped benefit social and economic situation is Saint Domingue, and allowed all workers of plantations to benefit from revenues, which is mentioned in article 16 of the Constitution (C). As the ruler, he claims himself to be there for life. There were some disadvantages, and some advantages to this situation. One advantage was Toussaint was a loyal person, and since people were used to his way of rule, they could become comfortable with him. However, he did become less popular over time, and eventually began to force labor on plantations. Toussaint enforces agricultural work because without the income of crops, France would have not been able to survive (C. In the Proclamation stated by Toussaint on November 25, 1801, he says that when a child is able to walk, he must be put on the fields to begin work (D). This shows how much he cared about the plantations, however it was a bit extreme, thus resulting in his popularity deteriorating. Also, the rules that were stated were driven to more forcefully enforce people to work, and consequences for breaking any of the rules would most likely be jail time (D). Remembering Toussaint as a ruler of Saint Domingue is important because it shows how he acted when in power, but it is not the most important because of his other major accomplishments.

Toussaint was one of the most remarkable men of his time, and is still considered an amazing man to this day. His legacy will carry on throughout all of history, and his successful revolution will continue to be taught and talked about for many more years. His revolution was like no other, and his ability on and off the battlefield as a military commander was truly great. As a ruler he ruled powerfully and did his best to let slavery never come back. Haiti is now a free country because of Toussaint, and the country would not be where it is now unless it was for him.


Bibliography:

Document A
Source: Created from various sources, “TimeLine of Abolition In Saint Domingue” Toussaint Louverture Mini-Q

Document B
Source: Toussaint Louverture, “Letter to the French Directory, NOvember 1797.” Toussaint Louverture Mini-Q

Document C
Source: “The Saint Domingue Constitution of 1801. Signed by Toussaint Louverture in July 1801.” Toussaint Louverture Mini-Q

Document D
Source: “Toussaint Louverture, Proclamation, 25 November 1801.” Toussaint Louverture Mini-Q

Document E
Source: “Madison Smartt Bell, Toussaint Louverture: A Biography, 2007.”

Document F
Source: William Wells Brown, “A Description of Toussaint Louverture,” from The Black Man, his Antecedents, his Genius, and His Achievements, 2nd edition. Engraving of Toussaint Louverture, 1802.

Thursday, November 13, 2014

Remembering a Revolution

There has never been a time where people do not stand up for what they believe in. Unjust ruling has been seen in hundreds of cases, and people who are being treated unfairly have the right to say something. However, even if a revolt of some type were to happen, it doe not mean they will always work.The essential question; ‘were the revolutions of 1830 and 1848 really failures as historians have said?’ questions whether or not historians were actually correct on all the revolutions being total failures. The question is asking if they were really failures because in some cases, there was a partial success. Most outcomes ended poorly, but others ended up having some good come out of them. It is important to see how they were somewhat successful, and in our class we broke up into groups of about four or five kids, and studied one specific revolution. Each of us read a summary about what the revolution was about, and looked at many primary sources to find out the true ending of the revolution. We then broke down the notes into topics like goals, opponents, and outcomes. Once we finished that the next task was to create a quiz for the rest of the groups to take. They would be allowed the exact same sources that our group had, and it was there job to do what they can with the given information to do well on the quiz. Each group made their own quizzes for the rest of the class to take.

The revolution my group studied was the Frankfurt revolution of 1848. The goal of this revolution was to create a constitutional monarchy that was fair and just. The german people wanted a national unity and liberal reforms. Also, they were debating on whether or not to join Austria, Prussia, or become their own independent states. Frederick WIlliam IV of Prussia was eventually asked to become the king of Germany, however he turned down the opportunity because it came from the people ‘from the gutters’ rather the princes. One primary source, titled “Between Myself and my People”, says “ One of the goals was to create a constitutional monarchy, "Frederick William IV tries to shut the door on the representatives’ demands for a democratic constitution." This quote shows the opponent, Frederick William IV, declining the opportunity to become king of Germany. Not only did he decline it, but he then sent in troops to wipe out the rebels who were revolting. Many rebels either died or were sent to prison, and many of them fled the country to the U.S. Another quote from Frederick William IV said, “I am not able to return a favorable reply to the offer of a crown on the part of the German National Assembly [meeting in Frankfurt], because the Assembly has not the right, without the consent of the German governments…” This shows the reasoning behind why William IV said not, and it was because his offer did not come from the government. Overall the revolution did end up in a failure. The people who were rebelling did not even know what they truly wanted. In the Frankfurt Assembly, there was no organization and development of ideas. If the plan was thought out a little bit more, than there might have been a different outcome.  

By using other examples of revolutions, it will be easier to answer the essential question. The first example, The revolution that took place in Hungary, ends up being only somewhat of a failure. The revolution had partial success because Metternich ended up fleeing, which forced the Austrian government to agree with the reforms. However the gains were only temporary, and many rebels were killed and put into jail. The second example, the Revolution in France of 1848, shows a complex, yet partially successful outcome. In the ‘June Days’ upper and middle class citizens had won control over the government, and shut down all national workshops. However some workers were furious and started to rally, and near 1500 people died before the government crushed the rebellion. But by the end of 1848, the National Assembly was able to restore order and have a constitutional for a second republic, and Louis Napoleon was put in charge. The third example is the French Revolution of 1830. Charles X was put in charge after Louis XVIII died, and he was not a very good king. After an uprising, he was forced to flee to England. After he left there was some debate as to how the country should controlled, and eventually the “Citizen King”, Louis Philippe, came to power. Many people liked him and Louis Philippe did a lot of good things for France. In my opinion of the essential question, I think that not all of the revolutions were total failures. The outcome of most of them was not successful, however some benefits, like kings fleeing and constitutional monarchies being appointed, shows that there was some positive benefits to the revolutions. '

Survey quiz of the Frankfurt revolution in 1848, click here: Frankfurt Revolution 1848

Which ideology did the Frankfurt Assembly follow?

  • Answered: 17 
  • Skipped: 0
ConservatismLiberalismNationalismAll threeNone
0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%100%

–
Conservatism
17.65%
3
–
Liberalism
52.94%
9
–
Nationalism
41.18%
7
–
All three
23.53%
4
–
None
11.76%
2
Total Respondents: 17
 
This screenshot shows one of the questions in our survey. It was important to know what ideology the Assembly was in favor for because shows the reasoning behind the things the people wanted, such as liberal ideas and a constitutional monarchy. 

Tuesday, October 28, 2014

Better To Be Safe Than Sorry


Power is a dangerous thing. It can go to people's heads and drive them crazy. Powerful people are feared and respected, but what should people in power do when their power is threatened? That question was the essential question we discussed in class, and there were a couple of solutions that were decided. One video clip that my class watched showed a scene where Napoleon and Klemons Von Metternich were talking about a possible peace treaty that Napoleon wanted. Metternich would only agree if Napoleon gave in to specific terms, such as giving his power up and restoring boundaries. After a lot of arguing, and one last battle, the battle of Waterloo that took place on June 18, 1815, Napoleon was defeated. The only questions were; what should the world do without him, and how should a government be run?


There were many ideas and reactions to Napoleon’s defeat. Ideas such as the Holy Alliance, and Principle of Intervention were all reactions of European power, but The principle of legitimacy made it possible for Metternich and other powerful people were able to keep their power without being threatened. The Principle of Legitimacy restored all lawful monarchs, and the Charter of 1814 made France a Constitutional Monarchy. Since Napoleon was not a monarch, other rules saw him as a threat to the ‘old order’ or old systems of running a government driven by a monarch. So, when Napoleon was defeated, the monarchs took back control and in places like France, it ended up being a constitutional monarchy. The constitutional monarchy allowed equal freedom and rights to any religion with protection from harm. It also allowed all Frenchmen equal before the law, whatever their titles may be. This would result in a better government and better lives for the people, while allowing the monarchs and higher class officials maintain power.

In some circumstances, giving up some power can be beneficial. The men who were threatened by power once Napoleon was defeated did a decent job at keeping their power, however if more freedom was given to citizens, then the monarchs or other powerful people could have felt more safe being in control. It makes sense to have a constitutional monarchy because without one then citizens would have most likely revolted fairly quickly and attempt to take out the monarchs. The constitutional monarchy allows more rights to citizens, and I believe that doing that was the right choice, because if it was strictly a monarchy then many powerful people would have felt a lot more threatened.



Napoleon and Metternich discussing a peace treaty is linked into this video here, which is labeled
Napoleon and Metternich. A lot of disagreement took place and one interesting thing was Napoleon claims Metternich to be insane when Metternich requests his demands. Napoleon did not want to give up his power, and he would fight till the end in order to prove it.

Wednesday, October 22, 2014

Undefined Ideologies


How to run a country and what form of government is best are topics that have long been debated and discussed. In class, we discussed different types of governments and government styles. The ideologies talked about were liberalism, conservatism and nationalism. The essential question in class was, "what were the major political ideologies of the 19th century and how did they influence social and political action?" This question can be answered by describing conservatism, liberalism and nationalism. Those were the 3 major views, and they affected social and political action, causing debates, uprisings and controversy. In class, we got into groups and read about one type of ideology. My group was assigned conservatism. Next, we had to come up with a one minute project about the ideology and make it as creative as possible. Each group was competing against one another, and we voted on a winner for each ideology.

My group made two short videos that were each thirty seconds long. We used Chatterpix and were able to make Edmund Burke, a conservative, talk about his views. Chatterpix is app which we used to take a picture and make it talk, and as a group our job was to record a dialogue about conservatism. Edmund Burke was a conservative, and his views were that government rule should stay the same and stick with tradition. Conservatists believe this because they feel that since a theory has worked in the past, it will work in the future. They say all the revolutions just cause death and chaos. They believed that organic solutions to political problems are the best way to go because people have seen them before. The presentation we made helps define ideology because Edmund Burke gives a description of why he likes conservatism. He provides facts about what it is to back up his reasons for liking it. He also includes his opinions of how power of the church and monarchies are the best solution to government. Another way our project describes conservatism is through Burke saying how tradition is the best way to go, and that too much chaos would come from anything else.

The two other ideologies, nationalism and liberalism, are very different from conservatism. One aspect of Nationalism is teaming up as a country or group of places based off on a common trait and taking out a foreign enemy. Traits like nationality, religion and language are able to bring people together, and if there is a common enemy, the nationalists will put aside any differences they have and defeat the enemy. One example of nationalism is Italy's first political party of nationalists founded in 1910. Italy was a nation that promoted the unity of Italians. They were ethnic, cultural and linguistic descendants of the ancient Romans.

Liberalism is an ideology that promotes new ideas and revolutions that improve society. Liberalism affected political and social action because there were many uprisings that occurred, and people wanted change so they could increase social class and get rid of monarchs. Liberalism was based on freedom, rights, and merit rather than traditional values. It was aimed mainly for the middle class, and liberals tended to not want poor people involved. That was one of the problems because liberalism did not help with poor people. Ideologies are still being debated now, and in the end there is no ‘correct’ way of running a government, it is simply based on opinion.

Sunday, October 12, 2014

One To Remember

In class, we studied and reviewed what Napoleon Bonaparte did that was so great. He took over almost all of Europe ands was able to overthrow tons of countries. His power was so great that he is still considered one of the most powerful men to this day. Some historians, such as Ida M. Tarbell, said things like ""He was the greatest genius of his time, perhaps of all time." She also said, "But he cannot refuse to acknowledge, that no man ever comprehended more clearly the splendid science of war." Napoleon was so powerful and so skilled at the art of war that nobody was able to take him down. Some of the places he was able to conquer were Belgium, Venice, Egypt, Austria, Vienna, Prussia, Berlin, and Spain. At one point, Boneapart Napoleon was able to control about two-thirds of Europe and have them under his rule. His power was so great that he seemed invisible.

The people of the countries that Napoleon took over were not enslaved, and not tortured or treated poorly. Many people could assume that since Napoleon was so powerful that everyone below him had almost nothing. In some cases, there were kings or rulers of other countries who were taken out of power, but for the most part people of the countries benefited a lot from Napoleon's rule. In France, there were many political benefits, and it was a nice time to be French because the country was very wealthy. Also, because of meritocracy, which is a way of running a government based on people's abilities, many people from all over Europe were able to benefit from their skills. The social benefits of Napoleon's reign were that people had more rights, access to educations and access to private property. Meritocracy was able to help people move up in social class towards a more beneficial life. France thrived economically. There was a balanced budget because prices were put under control. New industries formed, roads were built, and the Bank of France was adopted. Many people were able to have better lives under Napoleon's rule. 

Madame De Stael and Marshal Michel Ney were two people who had different views of Napoleon. Madame De Stael was a writer who hated him, and De Steal was eventually exiled from France. De Stael said that Napoleon was cruel and used force to get people to do what he wanted. She thought that Napoleon treated everyone below him poorly. She thought his way of running a government was poorly thought out, and that his systems would not work.
On the other hand, Marshal Michel Ney considered Napoleon to be great. He said that the emperor Napoleon deserved the right to rule over the country. Ney said that Napoleon supported and confirmed liberty, and that liberty was the most important thing in the end, something which could improve social class and wealth for many citizens. 

Napoleon was considered many things, but one thing that everyone agreed on was that he was the most powerful man during his time and possibly ever. Many benefits and positive outcomes arose from Napoleon's reign, and his rule will always be one to remember. 


Link to Lost Voices of Napoleonic History to read more about what famous historians thought of the great Napoleon Bonaparte. 
Napoleon Bonaparte was considered an emperor, and one of the greatest men of his time. This painting of him shows his strength, confidence, and courage.
http://www.gunclassics.com/napoleon.html







Wednesday, October 8, 2014

Political Views and Different Perspectives


In class we discussed multiple ways of running a country, and multiple ways of running a government. Two main ways that were brought up were the Invisible Hand theory by Adam Smith, and Marxism, established by Karl Marx. Both theories had different methods of running a government, and they had different ways of showing it. One of the main objectives of both theories was how to minimize the amount of poor people, and how to create an equal society during the Industrial Revolution. Each theory of government proved different points, all of which took considerable time to be proved.
Karl Marx was an intelligent man, and he wanted what was best for his country. His motivations and influences in life helped shaped his beliefs, and without his professor, his wife and a man named Friedrich Engels, he would have never been able to develop his theory. Marxism is close to communism, and Marx was the one who developed ideas of communism. He said that people would not want to have sharp divisions between rich and poor, and he felt that people would do whatever is necessary to ensure equality. Marx felt this equality would result in a stable society, and that capitalism would take to long to accomplish. Of it ties to long to accomplish, the people will revolt, and that is why Marx believed changing communism was the better solution.

Adam Smith thought differently from Marx. He came up with his own solution, which would allow competition, but provide a base from which poor people could work their way up. Smith wrote Wealth of Nations, which is a complex book that was written long before Marxism was introduced. The Invisible Hand, or Capitalism, was brought up and shown in a way that could benefit everyone. The Invisible Hand stated that everyone could compete at their own interest, and commerce and free immigration with minimal government would be allowed. These conditions would allow people to choose how they want to live. It allows competition between businesses, so that those with the lowest payments and highest qualities of goods will succeed. If someone were to be greedy and charge way too much for something of little value, then they will not succeed. The poor people are taken care of in this type of government because with free immigration, commerce and low government, they can eventually receive the high quality items for a lower price. They get a small building block to work with, and everyone can participate to their own desire.

In my opinion, Adam Smith’s theory of the Invisible Hand is the best solution. Even though Marxism provides fairness of wealth between everyone, it does not provide freedom for people to choose how they want to live. In the invisible Hand theory, low government control allows someone how they want to live. This is the best way in my opinion because everyone receives equal chance, but not equal payments. I believe that both ways will help poorer people succeed, but overall the Invisible Hand theory helps everyone create equal opportunity to choose how they want to live.



The Wealth of Nations, Written by Adam Smith, is a complex book discussing the way a country should be run. It  shows all Smith's political views in great detail.

The Invisible Hand was the theory by Adam Smith, and the link here is the basics of what Smith's views were about. 

Sunday, October 5, 2014

Independence Day

Work back in the 1800s during the Lowell experiment was a challenge that most women were up to. Many women worked at the mills, and at the mills there were many good things, but also many bad things. There were benefits from working hard, and many opportunities came from working. One reason young women were motivated to work was to provide for their families. Working was a good economical opportunity, and money could be sent home to help pay mortgages. Work was a struggle though-it was very hard for the women to do what they did. There were long work hours, conditions like wage cuts and strict bosses were some downsides of working at the mills. These conditions were very frustrating and did not make for an ideal workplace.

One of the main reasons women went to work was to have a life outside the mills. Women became independent and educated, qualities that helped them later in life. Work provided an opportunity to be set free from parents, and once the women were done working at the mills they could have a good life with plenty of experience under their belt. Women got 3 meals a day and were able to have total independence from family. An independent life taught responsibility. The corporations said that the work was more like an academy than a job, and the poorest of families were sent home money by their daughters. For the sake of their families, women put off marrying so that they could help financially.l This is another example of how life was more than just work at the mills. Women were motivated to gain financial independence, and this desire contributed to an increased number of women in the workplace. 


This picture shows two young girls working at the mills. Once their day is complete. the girls would receive a pay check and be able to go on with other activities, such as studying or playing with some of the other girls. It is important to know that life in the mills was not all work, and that girls had a life outside of it.
"Lowell Mills Girls"
http://www.massaflcio.org/sites/massaflcio.org/files/clip_image002.jpg