Thursday, April 30, 2015

Reaching Freedom From Below

If you want something done right, the best way to do it is to do it yourself. In history class, we learned all about how slaves during the Civil War gained their freedom, and it begged a very important question. The essential question that was given in class asks multiple things, but mainly focuses on where freedom came from for slaves. The term, freedom from below or above, recognizes and questions where freedom came from. From above refers to the less popular, but more wealthy class of upper-class citizens, or from people on higher social class. The term from below is the citizens, such as slaves, who are not wealthy and very low in social class. In class we were able to figure out the answer as to where freedom came from by analyzing documents and excerpts of Lincoln's famous quotes and speeches. Also, we viewed clips and made a diagram that shows where each of the Lincoln documents stand as to whither freedom came from above or below.

Some may argue that freedom came from below, and it could be proven through multiple documents. In the letter from General Ambrose E. Burnside to the secretary of War, Edmin M. Stanton, General Ambrose states how the slaves are uncontrollable. His forces had just taken over a city, but the place is being overrun by fugitive slaves. A lot of slaves were finally fed up with being treated the way they were and decided to do something about it. Also, another example was from President Lincoln's open letter to Horace Greeley, where Lincoln states how freeing the slaves is not a priority. He says how if he could do it, or it were to happen, than he would be happy with it. However, he says very clearly how saving the Union was his priority in war, and that freeing slaves was not. With this situation, it would be up to the slaves to free themselves, thus having freedom from below rather than above.


Some may argue that freedom came from above, and through some other documents that Lincoln has presented, it could show that slavery was in fact from above. First, the Emancipation Proclamation in January of 1863 announced that Lincoln was going to free the slaves. He said with the power vested in himself he would do his best and consider every act to give the slaves their true freedom. Also Second Inaugural Address, March 4 of 1865 , Lincoln is very upfront about his actions and opinion on slavery. He says that the whole reason of Civil War was to free the slaves, and he just never admitted it until now. In the Gettysburg Address, Lincoln mentions how the men who died will of did in vain, and that they will succeed in the war and free the slaves.

There has been multiple examples of social change coming from both below and above, and there are many points to consider when deciding whether change comes from below or above. One example that is somewhat recent was when Martin Luther King jr. stood up for what he believed in and decided to end segregation. Martin Luther King Junior was part of a lower social class, and he found enough people like him to rise to the occasion and do what is right. Personally, I think that for most cases, social change will come from the lower class, or from below, because they are the people who will want the changes. Citizens in upper class most likely enjoy the life they are living, so they would not want anything to change. When something needs to be done, I think that the people who are struggling through the situation are usually, but not always, not as wealthy or are lower in social class, and that is why they will make the change.


The image here is what we made in class to show which documents were from below or from above. It is a little hard to tell, but the ones closest to the right are from above, and the ones closest to the left are from below. 

Tuesday, April 7, 2015

The Battle Hunt





The damage and effects of war take an everlasting toll on the people and countries that are involved in the war. From 1861 - 1865, the Civil War took a terrible toll on all the people of the United States, and the consequences were severe. Throughout the war, many battles took place that affected both the North and South in many ways. Each side won different battles, and last week in class that is what we looked at. In class, we took part in a scavenger hunt for the Civil War battles. Each student was assigned a different battle that took place in the Civil War, and was to do research on it that included the battle name, date, place, victor, and theater, (east, west or naval) and the result as to why the outcome of the battle happened. After doing this, each student created a QR sign and linked it to their google drive with all the battle information on it. Next, we were ready to begin the hunt. Students went all around the school searching for the battle signs and each one gave a direction as to where the next would be, so you would know where to head next. As the hunt went on, we gathered all the information from each battle by taking a picture of the QR sign and then reading what it linked to. This process took about two days, and at the end we were able to complete the entire scavenger hunt.


There were two essential questions that we had to think about while learning about all the battles. The first one is, “Who was the ultimate victor in each of the theaters of war: East, West, Naval?” and the second is “What are some commonalities you can identify in the reasons for the results of the battles?” The first question is not as complex as the second, because by looking at the victors of each battle, it could clearly be seen who dominated each theater. In class, we used a website called padlet. This website was able to organize all our thoughts and information onto one picture to show who dominated what theater. In the West, it could be argued that the North dominated the theater. One reason is because the South were constantly lacking supplies, especially during the Siege of Vicksburg and Chattanooga Campaign. Also, at the battle of Shiloh, the North outnumbered the South troops by thousands of troops. In the East theater, there was much controversy as to who dominated the theater. It could be argued that the South states managed to hold down the East theater better than the North because of the organization and tactics used by the South. In the battle of Chancellorsville, the South had twice as many troops and used many advantages to take control of the East. In the Naval theater, meaning battle on the water, the Union dominated. They had many ironclads and much more powerful equipment than the South. The naval forces cut Southern trade to a third of its total levels. They blocked many water areas and captured thousands of blockade runners. In the battle of Fort Donelson and battle of Fort Henry, this is shown a lot.

After looking over the second essential question, a lot of commonalities can be seen. In the Western Theater, and throughout many battles that took place there, the South were constantly at a disadvantage. The North were constantly pushing in more troops and taking control of more areas. They had thousands of more troops and supplies than the south did throughout the entire war, and that was a huge effect in the battles. In the Naval theater, the same thing applies. The ironclads the North had were able to control the waters much better than the South could. Also, there was a naval base close to where some of the battles took place, which gave the North the upper hand because they were able to get resources faster. The north was so much more prepared that at one point the South completely gave up by taking down their own ship. Although there was controversy between who dominated the Eastern theater, there were still commonalities. The north held their grown by having a constant supply of troops, and even after 20,000 casualties there was still hope for the North. Also, the North had good plans to take control of some of the rivers. However, the South had control in that their organization was much better during the battles of Bull Run and Chancelorville. There generals knew what they were doing and this helped them have a little dominance in the Eastern theater. All these things that happened throughout the war affected the results and even if one battle ended up being different, there was no telling on what could have happened. I enjoyed doing this assignment because it was extremely knew and it was a fun way to take notes.  

This battle right here is the Battle of Chickamauga. It took place  September 19 and 20, 1863. The Confederate won and the theater it took place in was Western. This battle was a significant ending to the offensive tactics the North were  trying, and it gave a touch of hope to the confederate.