Thursday, April 30, 2015

Reaching Freedom From Below

If you want something done right, the best way to do it is to do it yourself. In history class, we learned all about how slaves during the Civil War gained their freedom, and it begged a very important question. The essential question that was given in class asks multiple things, but mainly focuses on where freedom came from for slaves. The term, freedom from below or above, recognizes and questions where freedom came from. From above refers to the less popular, but more wealthy class of upper-class citizens, or from people on higher social class. The term from below is the citizens, such as slaves, who are not wealthy and very low in social class. In class we were able to figure out the answer as to where freedom came from by analyzing documents and excerpts of Lincoln's famous quotes and speeches. Also, we viewed clips and made a diagram that shows where each of the Lincoln documents stand as to whither freedom came from above or below.

Some may argue that freedom came from below, and it could be proven through multiple documents. In the letter from General Ambrose E. Burnside to the secretary of War, Edmin M. Stanton, General Ambrose states how the slaves are uncontrollable. His forces had just taken over a city, but the place is being overrun by fugitive slaves. A lot of slaves were finally fed up with being treated the way they were and decided to do something about it. Also, another example was from President Lincoln's open letter to Horace Greeley, where Lincoln states how freeing the slaves is not a priority. He says how if he could do it, or it were to happen, than he would be happy with it. However, he says very clearly how saving the Union was his priority in war, and that freeing slaves was not. With this situation, it would be up to the slaves to free themselves, thus having freedom from below rather than above.


Some may argue that freedom came from above, and through some other documents that Lincoln has presented, it could show that slavery was in fact from above. First, the Emancipation Proclamation in January of 1863 announced that Lincoln was going to free the slaves. He said with the power vested in himself he would do his best and consider every act to give the slaves their true freedom. Also Second Inaugural Address, March 4 of 1865 , Lincoln is very upfront about his actions and opinion on slavery. He says that the whole reason of Civil War was to free the slaves, and he just never admitted it until now. In the Gettysburg Address, Lincoln mentions how the men who died will of did in vain, and that they will succeed in the war and free the slaves.

There has been multiple examples of social change coming from both below and above, and there are many points to consider when deciding whether change comes from below or above. One example that is somewhat recent was when Martin Luther King jr. stood up for what he believed in and decided to end segregation. Martin Luther King Junior was part of a lower social class, and he found enough people like him to rise to the occasion and do what is right. Personally, I think that for most cases, social change will come from the lower class, or from below, because they are the people who will want the changes. Citizens in upper class most likely enjoy the life they are living, so they would not want anything to change. When something needs to be done, I think that the people who are struggling through the situation are usually, but not always, not as wealthy or are lower in social class, and that is why they will make the change.


The image here is what we made in class to show which documents were from below or from above. It is a little hard to tell, but the ones closest to the right are from above, and the ones closest to the left are from below. 

No comments:

Post a Comment