In class we discussed multiple ways of running a country, and multiple ways of running a government. Two main ways that were brought up were the Invisible Hand theory by Adam Smith, and Marxism, established by Karl Marx. Both theories had different methods of running a government, and they had different ways of showing it. One of the main objectives of both theories was how to minimize the amount of poor people, and how to create an equal society during the Industrial Revolution. Each theory of government proved different points, all of which took considerable time to be proved.
Karl Marx was an intelligent man, and he wanted what was best for his country. His motivations and influences in life helped shaped his beliefs, and without his professor, his wife and a man named Friedrich Engels, he would have never been able to develop his theory. Marxism is close to communism, and Marx was the one who developed ideas of communism. He said that people would not want to have sharp divisions between rich and poor, and he felt that people would do whatever is necessary to ensure equality. Marx felt this equality would result in a stable society, and that capitalism would take to long to accomplish. Of it ties to long to accomplish, the people will revolt, and that is why Marx believed changing communism was the better solution.
Adam Smith thought differently from Marx. He came up with his own solution, which would allow competition, but provide a base from which poor people could work their way up. Smith wrote Wealth of Nations, which is a complex book that was written long before Marxism was introduced. The Invisible Hand, or Capitalism, was brought up and shown in a way that could benefit everyone. The Invisible Hand stated that everyone could compete at their own interest, and commerce and free immigration with minimal government would be allowed. These conditions would allow people to choose how they want to live. It allows competition between businesses, so that those with the lowest payments and highest qualities of goods will succeed. If someone were to be greedy and charge way too much for something of little value, then they will not succeed. The poor people are taken care of in this type of government because with free immigration, commerce and low government, they can eventually receive the high quality items for a lower price. They get a small building block to work with, and everyone can participate to their own desire.
In my opinion, Adam Smith’s theory of the Invisible Hand is the best solution. Even though Marxism provides fairness of wealth between everyone, it does not provide freedom for people to choose how they want to live. In the invisible Hand theory, low government control allows someone how they want to live. This is the best way in my opinion because everyone receives equal chance, but not equal payments. I believe that both ways will help poorer people succeed, but overall the Invisible Hand theory helps everyone create equal opportunity to choose how they want to live.
![]() |
| The Wealth of Nations, Written by Adam Smith, is a complex book discussing the way a country should be run. It shows all Smith's political views in great detail. The Invisible Hand was the theory by Adam Smith, and the link here is the basics of what Smith's views were about. |

No comments:
Post a Comment