In this weeks class of History, our class had the task to come up with our own essential question based off the unit we learned, which was on Native American life and the Buffalo soldiers. In order to come up with the essential question, we first started by watching multiple introduction videos and taking notes based on the main ideas, events, vocabulary, and main people involved. All these things directed us towards what life was like for Buffalo soldiers and native Americans. After that, we analyzed multiple documents, two being Helen Hunt Jackson's Century of Dishonor, and excerpts from the Dawes Act in 1887. After making sense of these documents, our class came up with the essential question; During westward expansion, did the impact of federal policy towards buffalo soldiers and Native Americans match the intent? This question is directed to how life changed for the Native Americans and Buffalo soldiers when federal policy of the American government came into play. The videos and document that we watched and looked at drove us toward coming up with a question like this because the government changed a lot of hints for the Native Americans and Buffalo soldiers, and even if the government thought it was for the best, it was not and it did not match the intent of what they were trying to do.
Native Americans and Buffalo soldiers lived a very great life until the government came and disrupted it all. The intent of the government was to take a lot of the Native American land and property while forcing the Native Americans to become farmers. Obviously the Native Americans did not want this and they fought back. Many battles and fights took place and many acts of total war took place too. The government then put in the Dawes Act, which forced the amount of land that Native Americans had to be reduced. All these things that the government did to native landowners ended up forcing them to move farther out and leave their homes. Even though the government thought that they were helping and protecting the Native Americans and buffalo soldiers, it ended up that they drove them out of their homeland and forced them to do things that were not part of their culture.
The image here shows a visual of Native American Federal Policies listed from the 1830s to 1890. It was one of the visuals we looked at in order to give us a better idea of how the American government took control over the Native Americans.
The American dream has been a great saying in the United States for a long time. The American dream can be interpreted in many different ways, depending on the person, but overall it says an American man or woman is lucky enough and has the ability to get a good job after finishing school, and enjoying working for whatever they may be doing. In class we studied the age of industry and the important people who made it happen. In class, we studied the age of industry by watching many videos and reading documents on John D Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie. Both of these men were powerful businessmen during this time and they influenced the way the age of industry was played out. After coming up with our own essential question, "Were the captains of industry a positive or a negative impact to the public?" I concluded that overall the captains of industry were in fact good for the public.
Many people could argue that the Robber Barons are corrupt morally, and they did not help the world of business. However, without their work, America would have to have waited a much longer time for manufacturing and business to grow in America, and by the 1900's these men created a much stronger country economically, technologically, and created a much high standard of living for many people. John D Rockefeller, being an extremely wealthy man, donated many millions of dollars to charity and schools. This helped the public because the money can go towards creating a better future for future generations. Also, Rockefeller's business strategies helped create extremely low prices on things such as oil and it allowed the consumers to buy things at low prices. This shows that Rockefeller's decisions helped the public as a whole, even though some other business owners and people thought he was morally corrupt.
Andrew Carnegie also contributed to the public in a positive way. As a steel manufacturer, Carnegie dedicated a vast majority of his time to create steel production in massive amounts at cheap prices for the public. Some may argue that he put other companies out of businesses, but his way of creating the products gave the public an easier time purchasing steel. Carnegie teamed up with Bessemer, who had introduced the Bessemer process of making steel more cheaply. All the decisions that Carnegie made helped the public become more stable and keep America growing financially. Just like Rockefeller, Carnegie create and donated a lot of money to schools and charities. This shows both men were considerate of people less fortunate than them and Rockefeller actually believed that he was a man who was meant to be successful in order to give back and donate to others. The captains of industry provided great service to the public and all these men were extraordinary businessmen who created a more successful America.
This image here shows a drawing of John D Rockefeller depicted as a royal tyrant. The image shows how he became Americas first billionaire and how he devoted his work to oil companies. Although other employees or businessmen thought of him as an unfair ruler, his actions still ended up putting America on top in the business world.
If you want something done right, the best way to do it is to do it yourself. In history class, we learned all about how slaves during the Civil War gained their freedom, and it begged a very important question. The essential question that was given in class asks multiple things, but mainly focuses on where freedom came from for slaves. The term, freedom from below or above, recognizes and questions where freedom came from. From above refers to the less popular, but more wealthy class of upper-class citizens, or from people on higher social class. The term from below is the citizens, such as slaves, who are not wealthy and very low in social class. In class we were able to figure out the answer as to where freedom came from by analyzing documents and excerpts of Lincoln's famous quotes and speeches. Also, we viewed clips and made a diagram that shows where each of the Lincoln documents stand as to whither freedom came from above or below.
Some may argue that freedom came from below, and it could be proven through multiple documents. In the letter from General Ambrose E. Burnside to the secretary of War, Edmin M. Stanton, General Ambrose states how the slaves are uncontrollable. His forces had just taken over a city, but the place is being overrun by fugitive slaves. A lot of slaves were finally fed up with being treated the way they were and decided to do something about it. Also, another example was from President Lincoln's open letter to Horace Greeley, where Lincoln states how freeing the slaves is not a priority. He says how if he could do it, or it were to happen, than he would be happy with it. However, he says very clearly how saving the Union was his priority in war, and that freeing slaves was not. With this situation, it would be up to the slaves to free themselves, thus having freedom from below rather than above.
Some may argue that freedom came from above, and through some other documents that Lincoln has presented, it could show that slavery was in fact from above. First, the Emancipation Proclamation in January of 1863 announced that Lincoln was going to free the slaves. He said with the power vested in himself he would do his best and consider every act to give the slaves their true freedom. Also Second Inaugural Address, March 4 of 1865 , Lincoln is very upfront about his actions and opinion on slavery. He says that the whole reason of Civil War was to free the slaves, and he just never admitted it until now. In the Gettysburg Address, Lincoln mentions how the men who died will of did in vain, and that they will succeed in the war and free the slaves.
There has been multiple examples of social change coming from both below and above, and there are many points to consider when deciding whether change comes from below or above. One example that is somewhat recent was when Martin Luther King jr. stood up for what he believed in and decided to end segregation. Martin Luther King Junior was part of a lower social class, and he found enough people like him to rise to the occasion and do what is right. Personally, I think that for most cases, social change will come from the lower class, or from below, because they are the people who will want the changes. Citizens in upper class most likely enjoy the life they are living, so they would not want anything to change. When something needs to be done, I think that the people who are struggling through the situation are usually, but not always, not as wealthy or are lower in social class, and that is why they will make the change.
The image here is what we made in class to show which documents were from below or from above. It is a little hard to tell, but the ones closest to the right are from above, and the ones closest to the left are from below.
The damage and effects of war take an everlasting toll on the people and countries that are involved in the war. From 1861 - 1865, the Civil War took a terrible toll on all the people of the United States, and the consequences were severe. Throughout the war, many battles took place that affected both the North and South in many ways. Each side won different battles, and last week in class that is what we looked at. In class, we took part in a scavenger hunt for the Civil War battles. Each student was assigned a different battle that took place in the Civil War, and was to do research on it that included the battle name, date, place, victor, and theater, (east, west or naval) and the result as to why the outcome of the battle happened. After doing this, each student created a QR sign and linked it to their google drive with all the battle information on it. Next, we were ready to begin the hunt. Students went all around the school searching for the battle signs and each one gave a direction as to where the next would be, so you would know where to head next. As the hunt went on, we gathered all the information from each battle by taking a picture of the QR sign and then reading what it linked to. This process took about two days, and at the end we were able to complete the entire scavenger hunt.
There were two essential questions that we had to think about while learning about all the battles. The first one is, “Who was the ultimate victor in each of the theaters of war: East, West, Naval?” and the second is “What are some commonalities you can identify in the reasons for the results of the battles?” The first question is not as complex as the second, because by looking at the victors of each battle, it could clearly be seen who dominated each theater. In class, we used a website called padlet. This website was able to organize all our thoughts and information onto one picture to show who dominated what theater. In the West, it could be argued that the North dominated the theater. One reason is because the South were constantly lacking supplies, especially during the Siege of Vicksburg and Chattanooga Campaign. Also, at the battle of Shiloh, the North outnumbered the South troops by thousands of troops. In the East theater, there was much controversy as to who dominated the theater. It could be argued that the South states managed to hold down the East theater better than the North because of the organization and tactics used by the South. In the battle of Chancellorsville, the South had twice as many troops and used many advantages to take control of the East. In the Naval theater, meaning battle on the water, the Union dominated. They had many ironclads and much more powerful equipment than the South. The naval forces cut Southern trade to a third of its total levels. They blocked many water areas and captured thousands of blockade runners. In the battle of Fort Donelson and battle of Fort Henry, this is shown a lot.
After looking over the second essential question, a lot of commonalities can be seen. In the Western Theater, and throughout many battles that took place there, the South were constantly at a disadvantage. The North were constantly pushing in more troops and taking control of more areas. They had thousands of more troops and supplies than the south did throughout the entire war, and that was a huge effect in the battles. In the Naval theater, the same thing applies. The ironclads the North had were able to control the waters much better than the South could. Also, there was a naval base close to where some of the battles took place, which gave the North the upper hand because they were able to get resources faster. The north was so much more prepared that at one point the South completely gave up by taking down their own ship. Although there was controversy between who dominated the Eastern theater, there were still commonalities. The north held their grown by having a constant supply of troops, and even after 20,000 casualties there was still hope for the North. Also, the North had good plans to take control of some of the rivers. However, the South had control in that their organization was much better during the battles of Bull Run and Chancelorville. There generals knew what they were doing and this helped them have a little dominance in the Eastern theater. All these things that happened throughout the war affected the results and even if one battle ended up being different, there was no telling on what could have happened. I enjoyed doing this assignment because it was extremely knew and it was a fun way to take notes.
This battle right here is the Battle of Chickamauga. It took place September 19 and 20, 1863. The Confederate won and the theater it took place in was Western. This battle was a significant ending to the offensive tactics the North were trying, and it gave a touch of hope to the confederate.
Some people say violence is never the answer, but some say that violence is the only way to solve disputes and major problems. In the early 19th century, the differences between the North and the South were so strong that many people thought the result was going to end up being war, and they were right. In class, we studied many of the events that led to the divisions between the North and South, and came to a conclusion. The essential question, "were the results of the election of 1860 representative of the deep divisions over slavery?" shows that there is a definite answer as to why the South withdrew themselves from the North. Once Lincoln was elected, the South feared that they would lose their right to keep slavery, and decided secession was the answer. South Carolina was the first to act, and many other states followed. In class, we created a video from Educreations and recorded voice-overs on how the events took place that led up to the war and the actions people took. The link to the video is below.
Church, Frederic. "Our banner in the sky." 1861.Terra Foundation for American Art, Daniel. Terra Collection. Accessed March 22, 2015.
In class we have been studying the rising actions that led to the Civil War. Many believed that this war was inevitable, and that no matter how many compromises there were it ended up resulting in a war. In the south, there was a number of slaves that men had and did not want to lose. In the North, there was patriotic beliefs that all men should be equal, and would go to war in order to solve their problems. We looked at many statistics on slavery and a lot of them were very shocking. One example is how there was literally millions of slaves all working with just one product, cotton. Cotton was a huge crop and supplied many southerners with the ability to be able to ship it to Europe in return for clothing and other material. This was a main reason the southerners did not want to lose their slaves because if they did, then they would not have a steady supply of cotton to export.
The facts I chose to include all show the main points and advantages that both the North and South had. In the infographic, there are descriptions on all the advantages both sides had, and how they utilized them. The charts show the numbers of slaves that worked in different fields of agriculture, and there are also descriptions and reasons as to why the Union and Confederate were fighting.
The process of making the infographic helped me understand these statistics more clearly because I could break down all the stats into smaller parts and see what was actually going on. Also, with the advantages that the North and the South had, you could see how break them up into smaller parts and see how each side of the war used their advantages. Overall I thought this way of studying the statistics of slavery and the civil war worked very well.
A lot of times in a conversation or debate, there is a really awkward problem that nobody wants to bring up because they do not want to be the one who announces the issue. Everybody in the room knows that there is something wrong, but nobody decides to bring it up. The saying for this is commonly known as “the elephant for the room” because the elephant is such a large animal and it so not usual to see it in an ordinary room, yet nobody comments on why it is there. In the United States of America, a classic way of seeing how slavery was the elephant in the room was when there was the huge debate between the North and South. Slavery was not officially abolished, and still legal in some ‘slave states’ which were in Southern America. In Northern America, there were ‘free states’ where slaves could become free. This begs the question, “How do we know the debate over slavery was the "elephant in the room" for American politics in the early 19th century?” As America grew the issue became drastic because nobody was sure of what to do with the territories that were becoming more populated. Many issues ended up having answers to them, but there was always a tension between the North and South, and it seemed almost inevitable that the civil war was going to happen.
In America, the first thing that citizens decided to do what the come up with a compromise to please both the Southern and Northern states. The compromise was named the Missouri Compromise, and it allowed Missouri to become a slave state, but nothing about the Missouri line could ever become a slave state. The reason Missouri became a slave state it because Maine wanted to enter the Union as a free state. When Missouri entered as a slave state, it allowed the balance of slave states and north states to become equal, which would allow fair vote in legislature. This worked for a little bit, but eventually California wanted to enter as a free state, which would offset the balance of free and slave states. Clearly, there was an obvious problem and one man, Henry Clay, thought he’d be able to fix it with a five part plan named the compromise of 1850. This plan would take away the Missouri Compromise, and it tried to make a balance between the North and South while pleasing everybody. Clay said that California will enter as a free state, and Texas will become a slave state and receive ten million dollars to help pay off debt. Also, Washington D.C would abolish slavery, and when other territories such as Utah, and Nevada become more populated, they will decide on what to do with them. This holds out yet another inevitable factor because once the areas become more populated, it will only cause more issues. The plans that were being made were only temporary, and nobody seemed to point it out.
Other issues that happened that made Slavery the elephant in the room were the Bleeding Kansas act and the Kansas Nebraska Act. Both of these things pushed people to their limits and made them realize that pushing this situation out any further was only going to cause more trouble. The Nebraska Kansas Act happened in 1854, and ultimately abolished the Missouri Compromise, which allowed Nebraska and Kansas to be on its own in the question of slavery. This act pleases southerns because now they have an opportunity to open up slavery more across America. However it also helped Chicago become very wealthy, making it part of transportation and commerce. This made another major city, and made the start to where north transcontinental railroad begins, allowing Northerns to make it possible to transport anti slave settlers into the north. The Bleeding Kansas Act of 1856 created a huge dilemma that pushed people to their limits. Many people such as John Brown, and senator of Massachusetts Charles Sumner were apart of this situation. John Brown and five other proslavery advocates raided antislavery houses and killed the men right in front of their families. Obviously this creates explosion between the North and the South, and many people had their own opinions on what should be done. The act that John Brown and his fellow advocates did began many more terrorizing acts in Kansas causing many deaths and bloody battles. Also, Charles Sumner gave a speech about how the southerns forced slavery upon Kansas, which makes the South look very bad. All these actions eventually led up to the Civil War, and nobody ever thought of trying to stop it before it became too late.
All these actions that took place eventually led to a bloody, sad, civil war. Nobody throughout the state could agree on what to do with all the new territories and whether or not they should have became slave states or free states. The actions and consequences may have been preventable, but since nobody decided to step up, everyone let slavery act as the elephant in the room.
These two images here show the timeline that was created in class. This was the project we did to help us understand the events leading up to the civil war more clearly, and it shows all up them by date with a description and image.
The United States of America stands for many great things and has many powerful symbols. One of the most important symbols our country represents is freedom. Every man and woman has the right to be free, and all humans should be treated the same, no matter what ethnicity or race. However, in the early 19th century, it was not always like this, and the states were put to the test when slavery was entrenched in economic society. Many Americans held slaves and nobody ever thought it was a bad thing. Slavery is degrading and puts many men and women in terrible conditions. Slavery was brought into America for many reasons, and it was not likely to change for a long time. Many slaves who were brought over from Africa were economical benefits for the slave owners. They were cheap labor, and did a lot of hard work. After slaves were examined, they were arranged to be sold. Someone would purchase the slave and keep him or her for their own benefits. Society craved slavery for many years during the early 19th century, and if something bad were to happen to a slave, it would be a big financial hit to the owner. One example is Prince Rahman, who was the son of the King of Futa Jallon. His owner, Thomas Foster, hated to see Prince Rahman run away because it was such a financial hit for him. This shows that slavery was a big deal at this time and was most likely not going to change for a while. Another thing that happened with Prince Rahman, and many other slaves, was taking leadership roles. Many of these slaves would train others and oversee them, which helped the owners out a lot. All these things that came from slavery were reasons as to why it became entrenched in society during the early 19th century.
Although slavery seemed like a good thing in the eyes of the owners, it was still a terrible thing to do to humans. All humans deserve rights and should be treated equally. Slaves would be beaten and treated poorly if work was not done to the owners demand. It is a degrading thing for any human, and since it was based off of race it was even more degrading for the African men who were enslaved. Africans would be shipped in a slave ship and put below deck, where many people were crammed and nobody noticed if someone died. The African men would be put to work and all the white men would torment them. This is degrading towards the Africans because it shows white men are more powerful than colored men, and it is just because of skin color. The African men are just as much humans as the white men are, so there should be no reason as to why the white men had more power of the people who they enslaved. Clearly, this was not a fair and something had to be done. However slavery lasted many years until is was abolished, and throughout the entire time it was degrading and affected human dignity the whole time.
A system of slavery based on race ignores many aspects of how life should be. All hard work done on the plantations and fields was done by the slaves, no matter how skilled they were at it. If one was not skilled at the job and did not do it well enough, they were most likely beaten. This was not fair and showed that the owners did not care about their slaves at all. If a white man was more skilled than a slave, he would still make the slave do the work. One thing that was interesting was that slave owners claimed that the slaves would rather be enslaved, than be free. Nothing can be assumed though because most, if not all men, would rather be free to live their own lives than having to be told what to do all the time. A system of slavery based on race effects human dignity in the eyes off the country as a whole, and the men and women who are being enslaved. There is a lot of hypocrisy involved in a situation like this because America claims to be a free country, yet they enslave so many men. This is degrading towards the men being enslaved and country because it is full of hypocritical people.
This Image here is the cover of the PBS film, "Prince Among Slaves" which is a documentary about Prince Rahman and his voyage to America as a slave. The video shows in great detail about how Prince Rahman became a slave, and then eventually went on to bigger and better things later on in his life.
There has never been a time where society did not neglect a certain type of people. It is sad to think of this but it is true. Whether it be a difference in religion, race or gender, people are always discriminating against one another, and it will most likely continue in the same path for many more years. Although there has been many significant changes in situations like this, and society is improving each and every day, there is still work to be done. True equality might not ever be reachable because there will always be the rich and always be the poor. However, treating people all the same no matter what level of social class is, and all it takes is more consideration.
In the mid-19th century, women were oppressed and ostracized out of everything a man could do. They could not vote, own property, or sign contracts, even if a husband lets her. Many rules and practices that women had to follow were listed and expected to be carried out. Some other
things women did not get were the same pay as men, even if the jobs were the same. One example of this is teaching, and in some instances women were paid only thirty to fifty percent of what men would make. Also, women could not speak out loud because it was considered improper. One real life example of a women being mistreated for her actions was Anne Hutchinson. Anne was a religious woman, and she was very smart and a good speaker. She spoke out loud to groups and preached religious ideas and thoughts. This was considered wrong because not only should an ordinary citizen be preaching about the Bible, but it it was a woman too. Anne was put on trial in court, and eventually banned from the colony. Unfair acts like this carried out for a long time, and it was only a matter of time before women starting standing up for themselves.
In July 1848, women decided enough was enough, and the first ever convention took place in order to act on equality for women. More than three hundred men and women took place in this convention, and it was named the Seneca Falls. In one article from The National Reformer, a quote says, “It being the first convention of the kind ever held, and one whose influence shall not cease until woman is guaranteed all rights now enjoyed by the other half of creation - Social - Civil- - Political.” This quote shows how important it was for women to be treated the same as men, and the author of this article believed that the convention would work and all humans would be treated equally. Being the first of many conventions, the Seneca Falls brought a lot of change to the world and made women more equal to men.
In today’s world, society has improved on equality and women are much more equal to men now. Although there is always work that can be done, a huge step in the right direction has been taken. Women can now be independent, and do not need a man to boss them around and tell them how to live. Women can vote, run for office, and get good jobs with much better pay. However, I believe there are still some stereotypes in the world today. Some things like a women will never be president, or women are not as smart as men or as strong as men. Things like this still exist in the world today, and as time goes on I think that there will be an improvement on it. Society is constantly changing, but right now things are looking pretty good.
Here is an image of the signing of the Seneca Falls Women's Rights Convention. Hundreds of men and women gathered at the meetings to put an end to abuse and inequality for women. Eventually, things were straightened out, and it all started from this one convention.
Citation: "The Declaration of Sentiments by the Seneca Falls Conference" (1848): A Common Core Exemplar. Humanities.http://edsitement.neh.gov. Accessed February 4, 2015.
The power of one man has the ability to effect a whole nation. It can change a whole way of life, and make people realize something they could have never thought of before. In the 19th century, many men used alcohol everyday. They would drink in the morning, at night, and all through the day. When people drink, vision becomes impaired, and people do things that they would not ordinarily do. Actions such as fighting would take place all the time. Drunk men would mistreat their families, and domestic violence took place, which put families in very tough situations. Many people who were religious thought that too much drinking would effect someone's connection with God. A lot of people tried to do something about it, and banning alcohol seemed to be the best way of having men become less addicted. One way was the Abstinence Pledge, which was a pledge used in 1845 that promoted healthy living and total abstinence of alcohol. At first, it was only used to promote abstinence from distilled liquors, but once the increase of wine and beer happened in the 1830's, the pledge was focused on absolutely no alcohol at all. This pledge became both a tactic and a public system to rid of all abuse of alcohol, and it was one of the first things that began to work towards the goal of banning drinking completely. Alcohol was first banned in Maine, and many states and places began to follow in the same path. Many temperance advocates stressed the goal of banning alcohol and the benefits of being pure. Advocates used 'purity' as a concept and way of separating alcohol from everyday life, and in this pledge, it shows the consequences of a drunken man, and the benefits of a sober living.
Presidents are considered and given the highest authority in the nation, but what happens when a President ruins his reputation by being selfish? A reputation is the way someone is looked at and seen as a person, whether it be a good thing, or a bad thing. In class we discussed Andrew Jackson and his reputation. The essential question, "Is Andrew Jackson's long standing reputation as "the people's president deserved? Why or why not?" shows that there it could be debated as whether or not Jackson deserved the reputation as the 'people's president'. Jackson was seen as someone who cared for the people, and someone who gave citizens what they deserved. However, in some cases it could be debated that Jackson was selfish, and very demanding. In the project I was apart of, we studied how the spoils system came into play and how it showed Jackson was selfish. The spoils system is when a President, such as Jackson, tells his citizens that if they vote for him, then the citizens will receive governmental jobs, even if they have no training in the field. This would almost guarantee people would vote for Jackson because government jobs are very well paid and provide high authority. This just shows that Jackson only cared about himself, even though he said all officials should be limited to four year terms. Although Andrew Jackson cared for the citizens and people of his country, he did not create any benefits from acting the way he did. Below is an embedded power point that goes into more detail about what the spoils system was. It was created by myself and my group members, and it provides images and examples of how Jackson used the spoils system to his advantage. One perfect example is when one man, who received a job from Jackson, stole over a million dollars from the bank. This man had many criminal charges on him before, but since he voted for Jackson, he got a job where he could pull off something like this.
In class, we have discussed the rise of democracy in the early 1800's, and how the United States came to be where it is today. After splitting up into groups, our task was to create a visual representation of the rise of democracy, and to answer the essential question, "How democratic was the United States in the early 1800's." In the poster that my group had, we defined democracy and wrote the essential question on the top of the poster. Next, we analyzed documents that were provided, and they helped us answer the question. As the years go on, Americans are required to pay more taxes, as illustrated in one of the tables on the poster, and in one of the paintings there is a lot of men sitting around and doing things like reading the newspaper. In one corner of the painting, a man received cider from an African and it is assumed that it is an exchange for a vote. At the time all white men were equal and had the right to vote for their leaders, but women and Africans did not have that right.
The poster shows the analyzed data and definition of democracy. Our group did our best to answer the essential question by using the tables and charts in order shows how democratic the U.S was in the early 1800's.
All people deserve a chance. No matter what the circumstance may be, humans deserve an equal right and opportunity to be successful in life. Men and women should not be put down because of what religion, race, or ethnic background they come from. It is important to see people for how they act, rather than how they look. In class, we studied Latin American Revolutions and why they happened. The essential question in class was, "why is it to essential to acknowledge human value regardless of race?" and "How are the events in the Latin America revolutions evidence of this social imperative?" These questions are important to look at because it helps identify the true meaning of human value. Humans should all be valued and treated the same, regardless of race. In Latin America, many people who were not Peninsulares or creoles were put down and treated poorly. The term imperative, meaning importance is used in the second question because the revolutions that took place in Latin America show true evidence that social and economic benefits should not come from what race someone is. In class we were handed different charts and timelines from three of the Latin American Revolutions, Mexico, Gran Colombia, and Brazil. After studying these elements we were able to come up with an answer to the essential question.
The timeline that the group I was apart of is shown at the end of this post, and it shows how Mexico's revolution took place. In the three revolutions, there were many common things that occured, and also some differences too. Some of the common things that took place were all the revolutions were successful, which means they all ended up with their own independence, and each country was able to break apart from their former ruling countries. One difference is how each of the countries gained their independence. Mexico became a constitutional monarchy, and Colombia was able to overthrow the Spanish army because of Simon Bolivar, who led a revolution that consisted of primarily of creoles and lower status citizens. The Peninsulares would not be apart of this revolution because they had everything they needed. However, this group of people was made up of about one percent of the population, and the rest was of lower status people. The same thing was in Mexico and Brazil, where most of the citizens were not Peninsulares. Race was an issue in all three revolutions because each one had the men of lower class being treated the worst. If someone were of color or not from European deceant, then their life in the new world would not have been great. So, that is why they wanted to start a revolution. It was so people of all races could gain independence.
In todays life, racial differences is still among us, and no matter how long it takes, I believe there will always be a small group of people who are racist towards another group. The issue has gone down significantly since the end of the civil war, however stereotypes are still being used and scene in everyday life. There has been many issues on the news where a white police officer has shot a black man. In some cases, people think the officer had no right shooting the man, and in other cases, people say the black man was doing something wrong where matters needed to be taken care of. The biggest debate scene in these situations is that many people think the officer was assuming the black man was doing something wrong, and shot him because the officer was racist. There has been at least three of these situations in the past year, including the George Zimmerman trial, and the recent shootings in a few other states. Racism has been around for many years, but it has gone down a lot. It is very important to consider the issue in today's life because it could easily come back. In society today, it is important to recognize racism and do our best to keep it out of our lives.
Timeline:
In 1820, liberals took power in Spain and a new government that promised reforms to stop Mexican revolutions. Mexican conservatives wanted independence so they could maintain their positions and beliefs.
In 1821, Agustin de Iturbide negotiated the plan of Iguala with Vicente Guerrero. It made Mexico an independent constitutional monarchy.
August 24, 1822, Spanish Viceroy Juan de O'Donoju signed the treaty of Cordada making Mexico officially an independent constitutional monarchy.
1822, Iturbide was proclaimed the emperor of Mexico.
1823, republican leaders Santa Anna and Guadalupe Victoriano turned Mexico into a republic. This is a snapshot of what Race population looked like in Mexico. As seen in the chart, there are very few of the Peninsulares, however they were the group of people who wealthier and controlled more land than anyone.
Never underestimate the power of a man who fights for what he believes in. The strength of man when the masses rise are almost impossible to overcome. In Saint Domingue, 1791, one man, Toussaint Louverture. finally said enough was enough, and he took matters into his own hands. The biggest slave revolt in history was about to happen. Toussaint fought for what he believed in. He was a true fighter for freedom and abolishment of slavery, and no matter what side supported the slaves, that would be the side he joined. In 1793, Toussaint was in control of an army of rebels and slaves that consisted of over four thousand men. They fought the French to the death and eventually abolished slavery in 1794. Now that the French supported the slaves, Toussaint joined them and became the ruler of the French army, making him the most powerful person in the island. St. Domingue was the western half of Hispaniola, and it was ruled by the French. They produced many crops such as sugar and coffee, and without the island France would have had trouble surviving. Toussaint ruled this part of the island until 1802, until Napoleon came and attacked the French army, trying to reinstate slavery. Eventually Napoleon retreated, but Toussaint was captured and died in jail. The question, "how should we remember Toussaint Louverture?" Is a very good question because there are many different things that he can be indent infield as. Toussaint Louverture should be remembered as the liberator so slaves, his ability to be a great military leader, and his job as commander of Saint Domingue. Although his military leadership and ruler of saint Domingue is important, his ability to liberate slaves is the most important because he was the successful leader of the biggest slave revolt in history.
The slave revolt that took place in Saint Domingue was the most important, and most successful slave revolt in history, and it was able to happen because of Toussaint Louverture. In 1791, the slave revolt began, and Toussaint Louverture joins the rebellion as a doctor (A). In 1792, he began to lead the army and taught his troops how to fight in different styles, like European battle and guerrilla style (A). Before this, in 1789, the French Revolution began and free black men of color in saint Domingue proclaimed themselves French citizens (A). The declaration of rights of men triggered the slave revolt once white men refused to end slavery. Once the revolution was over, and Toussaint and the slaves were free, the French directory was the government that ruled France. They ruled from 1795 to 1799, and Toussaint believed that they were going to reinstate slavery (B). Toussaint wrote a letter to the directory saying that if they were to attempt to reinstate slavery, then it would be impossible. He says that once men get a taste of what liberty is like they will never go back to being enslaved. The threat in the letter says that if slavery comes back there will be another war (B). In 1801, Toussaint led and assembled Saint Domingue's Constitution, which promised rules and policies that would keep former slaves free (C). On example, from article 3 of the constitution, says "there cannot exist slaves in this territory! servitude is therein forever abolished. All men are born and die free and French." This shows with great emphasis on how much Toussaint cared about keeping slaves free. He cared about social and economic welfare, and preserved the liberation of slaves, making him a very honorable man.
One of the main reasons Toussaint was about to be so successful in his revolution was because of how great of a military commander he was. HIs ability both on and off the battlefield was superior to others, and without him in control, the revolution would have failed. One example is that Toussaint trained him men in multiple tactics of war, thus giving them an advantage when on the battlefield (A). Also, when Toussaint began to force labor back onto the plantations, and a revolt occurred on the night of October 29, 1801, he stuck to his roots and did not let the mutineer get his way (E). He forced Moyse, who was Toussaint's adopted nephew, to be arrested and executed (E). This shows that Toussaint would not let anyone get out of control while he was in command, and he was able to react quickly to soldiers and plantation workers who were out of place. Another example was when Napoleon came and attacked Saint Domingue. When Toussaint saw the ships, he burned down the city and took him and his troops to the mountains (F). He fled there because his troops were familiar with the territory, whereas Napoleons men were not. This would give them the ability to run a guerilla war type of battle and force the European army away (F). He burned down the city so Napoleon's troops would have no base to set up at, and all the resources that could have been used were gone (F). Smart moves like this showed how great of a military commander Toussaint Louverture was, and his success on the battlefield brought Saint Domingue to peace.
Not only was Toussaint a military leader, but he was the ruler of Saint Domingue, and in 1801, he was able to create Saint Domingue's Constitution of 1801. This allowed more than just slavery to never occur again. It helped benefit social and economic situation is Saint Domingue, and allowed all workers of plantations to benefit from revenues, which is mentioned in article 16 of the Constitution (C). As the ruler, he claims himself to be there for life. There were some disadvantages, and some advantages to this situation. One advantage was Toussaint was a loyal person, and since people were used to his way of rule, they could become comfortable with him. However, he did become less popular over time, and eventually began to force labor on plantations. Toussaint enforces agricultural work because without the income of crops, France would have not been able to survive (C. In the Proclamation stated by Toussaint on November 25, 1801, he says that when a child is able to walk, he must be put on the fields to begin work (D). This shows how much he cared about the plantations, however it was a bit extreme, thus resulting in his popularity deteriorating. Also, the rules that were stated were driven to more forcefully enforce people to work, and consequences for breaking any of the rules would most likely be jail time (D). Remembering Toussaint as a ruler of Saint Domingue is important because it shows how he acted when in power, but it is not the most important because of his other major accomplishments.
Toussaint was one of the most remarkable men of his time, and is still considered an amazing man to this day. His legacy will carry on throughout all of history, and his successful revolution will continue to be taught and talked about for many more years. His revolution was like no other, and his ability on and off the battlefield as a military commander was truly great. As a ruler he ruled powerfully and did his best to let slavery never come back. Haiti is now a free country because of Toussaint, and the country would not be where it is now unless it was for him.
Bibliography:
Document A
Source: Created from various sources, “TimeLine of Abolition In Saint Domingue” Toussaint Louverture Mini-Q
Document B
Source: Toussaint Louverture, “Letter to the French Directory, NOvember 1797.” Toussaint Louverture Mini-Q
Document C
Source: “The Saint Domingue Constitution of 1801. Signed by Toussaint Louverture in July 1801.” Toussaint Louverture Mini-Q
Document D
Source: “Toussaint Louverture, Proclamation, 25 November 1801.” Toussaint Louverture Mini-Q
Document E
Source: “Madison Smartt Bell, Toussaint Louverture: A Biography, 2007.”
Document F
Source: William Wells Brown, “A Description of Toussaint Louverture,” from The Black Man, his Antecedents, his Genius, and His Achievements, 2nd edition. Engraving of Toussaint Louverture, 1802.
There has never been a time where people do not stand up for what they believe in. Unjust ruling has been seen in hundreds of cases, and people who are being treated unfairly have the right to say something. However, even if a revolt of some type were to happen, it doe not mean they will always work.The essential question; ‘were the revolutions of 1830 and 1848 really failures as historians have said?’ questions whether or not historians were actually correct on all the revolutions being total failures. The question is asking if they were really failures because in some cases, there was a partial success. Most outcomes ended poorly, but others ended up having some good come out of them. It is important to see how they were somewhat successful, and in our class we broke up into groups of about four or five kids, and studied one specific revolution. Each of us read a summary about what the revolution was about, and looked at many primary sources to find out the true ending of the revolution. We then broke down the notes into topics like goals, opponents, and outcomes. Once we finished that the next task was to create a quiz for the rest of the groups to take. They would be allowed the exact same sources that our group had, and it was there job to do what they can with the given information to do well on the quiz. Each group made their own quizzes for the rest of the class to take.
The revolution my group studied was the Frankfurt revolution of 1848. The goal of this revolution was to create a constitutional monarchy that was fair and just. The german people wanted a national unity and liberal reforms. Also, they were debating on whether or not to join Austria, Prussia, or become their own independent states. Frederick WIlliam IV of Prussia was eventually asked to become the king of Germany, however he turned down the opportunity because it came from the people ‘from the gutters’ rather the princes. One primary source, titled “Between Myself and my People”, says “ One of the goals was to create a constitutional monarchy, "Frederick William IV tries to shut the door on the representatives’ demands for a democratic constitution."This quote shows the opponent, Frederick William IV, declining the opportunity to become king of Germany. Not only did he decline it, but he then sent in troops to wipe out the rebels who were revolting. Many rebels either died or were sent to prison, and many of them fled the country to the U.S. Another quote from Frederick William IV said, “I am not able to return a favorable reply to the offer of a crown on the part of the German National Assembly [meeting in Frankfurt], because the Assembly has not the right, without the consent of the German governments…” This shows the reasoning behind why William IV said not, and it was because his offer did not come from the government. Overall the revolution did end up in a failure. The people who were rebelling did not even know what they truly wanted. In the Frankfurt Assembly, there was no organization and development of ideas. If the plan was thought out a little bit more, than there might have been a different outcome.
By using other examples of revolutions, it will be easier to answer the essential question. The first example, The revolution that took place in Hungary, ends up being only somewhat of a failure. The revolution had partial success because Metternich ended up fleeing, which forced the Austrian government to agree with the reforms. However the gains were only temporary, and many rebels were killed and put into jail. The second example, the Revolution in France of 1848, shows a complex, yet partially successful outcome. In the ‘June Days’ upper and middle class citizens had won control over the government, and shut down all national workshops. However some workers were furious and started to rally, and near 1500 people died before the government crushed the rebellion. But by the end of 1848, the National Assembly was able to restore order and have a constitutional for a second republic, and Louis Napoleon was put in charge. The third example is the French Revolution of 1830. Charles X was put in charge after Louis XVIII died, and he was not a very good king. After an uprising, he was forced to flee to England. After he left there was some debate as to how the country should controlled, and eventually the “Citizen King”, Louis Philippe, came to power. Many people liked him and Louis Philippe did a lot of good things for France. In my opinion of the essential question, I think that not all of the revolutions were total failures. The outcome of most of them was not successful, however some benefits, like kings fleeing and constitutional monarchies being appointed, shows that there was some positive benefits to the revolutions. '
This screenshot shows one of the questions in our survey. It was important to know what ideology the Assembly was in favor for because shows the reasoning behind the things the people wanted, such as liberal ideas and a constitutional monarchy.